Privacy Policy
> Home page > Science Fairs > A few hints about judging > A question of practice
A few hints
about judging
Unfinished
projects
A word from
one of our
judges
Evaluation
Sheet
A question of practice

The following information is taken from Expérimentez l'Expo-sciences created by the Conseil du loisir scientifique in partnership with Merck Frosst Canada Ltd. and the ministère de la Culture et des Communications du Québec.

Experiments are judged largely on criteria related to the analysis and the discussion. Focus on the scientific method, since the value of your experiment lies in your method. All the steps are important, but keep in mind that you don't have all day to present your project.


Make good use of your time

Briefly discuss how you developed the idea for your project (it will put the judge immediately at ease). Do a quick overview of your experiment; you don't have to go into specific details. Your presentation should focus primarily on the experimental process, the analysis and the significance of your experiment. If necessary, you can go back to the actual experimenting. If you had to start over and over in different ways, you can mention it, but don't dwell on it. The judge isn't there to feel sorry for you.

If the judge has no questions, try to involve him or her by asking a question or by having him or her anticipate the next step. Test his or her understanding. The more you pay attention to your judge, the better your presentation will be. Focus on his or her participation. Try not to be too friendly or pretentious. Finding an appropriate middle ground will help you develop the best rapport with the judges.


One last bit of advice

Pay special attention to the visual elements of your presentation. Although this may not be the most important evaluation component, it is an important element as far as comprehension and presentation are concerned. If you're not convinced, conduct the following tiny experiment. Tell a friend about a bit of gossip without revealing who it is about or what actually happened. You will quickly realize that a picture is worth a thousand words. A judge will more readily understand a graph or an illustration than a lengthy explanation. Remember, with only 20 to 30 minutes, you have to make every minute count.

If you have time left over, discuss the topic with your judge and allow him or her to ask questions. If the judge has no questions and leaves early, don't worry about it and use the extra time to rest before the next judge arrives. Better to end five minutes early than to run out of time.

How do you prepare
for the judging?

MPEG | 8.1 MB

Do you have any tips you
would like to share?

MPEG | 9 MB





© 2002, Conseil de développement du loisir scientifique (CDLS). This document is distributed by the Conseil de développement du loisir scientifique.
For more information, visit our Web site at www.cdls.qc.ca.
The opinions expressed in this section are those of the authors and do not necessarily
reflect the opinions of Merck Frosst or its employees.